11/3/2023 0 Comments Time out corner adult![]() ![]() Having a child stand in the corner may seem helpful at the time because it takes them out of a situation and makes an example out of them for any other children present, but it is a shaming strategy and can have serious long-term consequences. Over the past 40 years, a great deal of scientific research has been conducted on the shaming of children and has confirmed that it is a bad idea.Īlthough most people agree that making a child wear the dunce cap is a poor decision, the dunce corner has not been as easy to eliminate.Įven if we don’t call it that in the U.S., that is what it is. The science on the subject supports this as well. Once we look at the history of this practice it does not appear to come from a place that is beneficial to children. It produces a similar culture of shame that the Victorian practice did and does nothing to help the child learn from their mistake with dignity and respect.Īny disciplinary action you choose to implement with your child should have their best interests at heart and should be carried out with love and empathy so that they can grow from it. For those willing to understand the history and original intent of the practice, it is clear that separating kids from others and putting them on display in front of them is not healthy. they still call it the dunce’s corner.Īlthough we don’t call it that here in the U.S., it is used for the same purpose. ![]() However, some remnants of the era, like putting children in the corner still remain. Later as the Renaissance and the Enlightenment produced great thinkers and ideas, his views and the name Duns (pronounced dunce) itself became synonymous with “idiocy”.Īfter the Victorian period, our society slowly realized that shaming kids was wrong and we have moved away from the practice. He was a philosopher during the Medieval period that believed pointed hats stimulated the brain and funneled wisdom to the person who wore it, presumably from the heavens. Each approach got its name from the same place as the dunce cap itself, John Duns Scotus (born around 1266). ![]() Each method was intended to produce the same outcome, compliance through shame. The idea was that all students would want to avoid being put on display in front of the class or labeled a “dunce”. They were sent to stand in the dunce corner, sit at a designated dunce table, and/or wear the infamous dunce cap. The idea of having a child stand in the corner was most famously used as a strategy in Victorian England and at about the same time in America when punitive discipline was the primary tool for maintaining control of kids. I’ll talk a little about where this practice comes from and whether the science says it’s effective, then I will talk about what you can do instead to ensure your children grow into disciplined and respecftul young adults. In this case, believe it or not, the roots of the idea are almost as old as the scientific method itself and the practice is about 200 years old. ![]() It is sometimes easy to forget that the things that we do today have their roots in historic practices that long predate any modern existing science and research. History tells us that it’s cruel and science tells us that it creates issues for the child later in life that greatly outweighs the perceived benefits. Standing in the corner as a form of punishment is not healthy for the child. Is standing in the corner a good punishment? No. Where does having a child stand in the corner fall? I took some time researching the answer to find out. Some are still fine to use today, while others can be truly harmful. These days it’s hard to tell which traditional punishments are a bad idea and which are just simply out of style. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |